Large Dog Treat Pouch Training Kit with Clicker, Waist Pack Puppy Treat Bag with Poop Bag Dispenser and Clip for Belt, Big Dog Walking Pouches with Dog Clickers and Silent Whistle

Just wish the belt was longer. Plenty of room. Not structured enough to allow one hand access to anything but still good.

Training a ninety pound dog and needed all the help I could get. This works great

I have another dog treat bag that i much prefer over this one since that other one has a waist/belt loop attachment PLUS a convenient over the shoulder strap which is how I prefer to carry my dog treats since I can easily move the bag behind my back out of view of my puppies or pull it forward (which is far less easy to do when you have it attached at your waist)... so I got this bag mostly for the included dog whistle which and to have a back up bag in case I lost or misplaced my other one. Unfortunately, the dog whistle has a ring on it that is attached to the plastic CAP end of the dog whistle (and the cap serves no purpose) instead of being attached to the metal dog whistle itself, and the plastic cap end falls off very easily. Even though I had the whistle cap attached to a long neck loop and attached directly to the dog treats bag with a metal clip AND tucked securely inside the outer pocket of my dog treats bag where I could access it easily, somehow the whistle and cap still managed to fall out of the bag and since the only way to attach the whistle to the neck cord was by attaching to the loop on the CAP (instead of having an attachment ring on the whistle part itself), the whistle was promptly lost even though I still have the useless cap. LOLThe treats bag itself is well made and spacious, so if you like the belt loop style, you might like this bag. But overpriced since a lot of the price is for the whistle and the clicker (which I didn't need since I use verbal training cues since you always have those with you). Just note that if you're getting it for the dog whistle, because of the fact that they put the attaching loop on the cap instead of my more intelligently putting the attaching loop on the whistle itself, you'll never be able to carry the whistle around your neck or keep it anywhere else handy since it will probably get lost very quickly (although, you'll still have the cap - yay. ;) )

I really like this little pouch. It has treats and poopie bags. I only wish it were more light weight. Good for hikes and such but a little cumbersome for every day around the house bag.

For treats, keys, and cellphone. Not bulky.

Finding myself with an unexpected, boisterous 80-pound foster puppy, I needed a training-treat bag quickly. At the current price ($19.99), this treat bag costs more than many others, but I’m really glad I bit the bullet and went for the higher-priced bag. I’ve used cheaper ones in the past and they are either designed badly or don’t last long. This bag is a perfect size (not too big, not too small), the overall layout is nearly perfect, and it seems super-sturdy. I expect it will hold up well for many years.The canvas-like material feels very heavy-duty and the stitching is really solid. I wasn’t sure if I would like a zippered treat compartment (as opposed to the magnetic open/close models I looked at), but now I realize that a zipper is definitely the way to go. When actively training a puppy, I want to get to the treats quickly; leaving the top compartment open is much easier than having to fumble around constantly with self-closing mechanisms. To avoid spills, I never fill the compartment more than halfway (which is still a lot of treats) and even during very active training sessions, not one treat has fallen out. And when it’s zipped closed, you never have to worry about it opening accidentally.The bag has a built-in carabiner-like belt-loop clip as well as an adjustable waist belt (which slides through a wide, sturdily sewn pocket across the back of the bag). I would love to use the belt-loop clip because it looks a lot less dorky, but I find that the “fanny pack” method is more secure and works better for me.Note re belt adjustment: Even the best of these adjustable belts tend to loosen up over time, especially if you’re running around. Since I’m the only person using the bag, I adjusted the size carefully and then added two small red stitches in the belt (see photo). It took all of 10 minutes (and I’m not great with a needle and thread) and now I’ll never have to worry about re-adjusting the belt (as long as I don’t gain weight, that is).The vertical-zipper compartment on the front is handy and has a built-in clip to ensure your keychain doesn’t slip out even if the zipper somehow opens accidentally (which I doubt would ever happen). The built-in bag dispenser holds plenty of bags, works really well and is a must-have feature.The only thing I don’t love about this bag is the elastic mesh pocket. Unless you have a pretty small phone without a case, I doubt it will fit. They should have put the mesh pocket on the front of the bag and made it bigger. So I’m stuck keeping my phone in my pocket, but that’s a small trade-off for the quality, functionality and durability of the bag.The included clicker is one of the good ones; it’s very sturdy and produces a strong click. (I already had a similar one, and it’s still going strong after 10+ years.)As for the included dog whistle, what can I say? I’m not a dog-whistle person, and my foster puppy didn’t even seem to notice the sound, regardless of how I adjusted the frequency. The whistle looks solid, though, so if you like dog whistles, you’ll probably think this is a good one.The color of the bag is also great — the red is vibrant, but not obnoxious. It looks sporty, but professional. (On the product page, the photos make it look sort of brownish-red, and my phone camera makes it look kind of pinkish-red. It’s neither — it is red-red.)If you’re looking for a high-quality, durable, easy-to-use training-treat bag, I highly recommend this one.5 stars.

This training bag is great! Has many compartments for phone, poop bags, treats, and more and stays securely around waist. Well made and love the color. Haven't trained with the clicker but seems well made and nice loud click.

Definitely great for any walk to carry treats and any other accessories along (doggie bags etc).Works great for training as well, used this to do some leash training with my pup and was great!